A brief league history (2007-2025):
Click here to view the trophy case (2023 – present)
*The number in parentheses next to the team name represents the number of awards won by the manager at that level.
| Year | “Best of the Fresh” | “Kinda Fresh” | “Not So Fresh” | “Best of the Unfresh” | “Putrid” | “Master Prognosticator” | Points Leader |
| 2007 | 2 Getyourhead outofyour (1) | 1 Teflon Don (1) | 4 Kevin’s Smokin’ Team (1) | Footbawwwl (1) | My clever name (1) | N/A | Teflon Don (1) |
| 2008 | 1 No Haters Allowed (1) | 3 les concasseurs (1) | 2 Choke artist (1) | Evil Monkey (1) | Teflon Don (1) | N/A | Choke artist (1) |
| 2009 | 1 Evil Monkey (1) | 2 2 Mannings 1 Cup (1) | 3 Ballsweat Express (1) | Mad Hatters (1) | Mayabutt smells (1) | N/A | 2 Mannings 1 Cup (1) |
| 2010 | 3 G.O.A.T. (1) | 4 Nous le mieux!! (2) | 2 Mayabutt smells (1) | Scrappin’ Spartans (1) | No Haters Allowed (1) | N/A | Choke City (2) |
| 2011 | 2 Scrappin’ Spartans (1) | 5 l’assassin… (3) | 1 Lebum (2) | URANUS (1) | TeknikS (1) | N/A | Lebum (3) |
| 2012 | 5 The Fresh Crew (1) | 3 No Haters Allowed (1) | 2 Brady’s Ballers (1) | Nemesis (2) | Scrappin’ Spartans (1) | idontliketolose (1) | Brady’s Ballers (1) |
| 2013 | 1 The Fresh Crew (2) | 3 The Great One (1) | 4 TeknikS (1) | Falconed by JuliNo (1) | Hostile Takeover (1) | The Fresh Crew (1) | The Fresh Crew (1) |
| 2014 | 1 Nemesis (2) | 6 ya bI$H (1) | 2 Stairway to Seven (1) | The Fresh Crew (1) | TeknikS (2) | Nemesis (1) | Stairway to Seven (1) |
| 2015 | 2 Stairway to Seven (1) | 1 Henry P. McCoy (4) | 4 The Fresh Crew (1) | The LuckLess Monster (1) | No Comment (2) | Nemesis (2) | Stairway to Seven (2) |
| 2016 | 3 Nemesis (3) | 1 Jacob High Rollers (1) | 5 The Fresh Crew (2) | the big F ish (2) | KING of Bench Points (1) | Nemesis (3) | Nemesis (1) |
| 2017 | 5 Nemesis (4) | 1 Sandy Ravage (1) | 6 Stairway to Seven (2) | the big F ish (3) | Henry P. McCoy (1) | The Bad Guy (1) | Sandy Ravage (1) |
| 2018 | 1 Dirty Laundry (1) | 2 The Fresh Crew (1) | 3 KING of Bench Points (1) | Slimbo Kice (1) | Hostile Takeover (2) | The Fresh Crew (2) | The Fresh Crew (2) |
| 2019 | 1 The Great One (1) | 5 From the Ashes (2) | 6 Tha Preda~Toe (1) | Double Doink (1) | Mr. steal yo Gurley (1) | The Great One (1) | A.J.’s Back (1) |
| 2020 | 2 Dirty Laundry (2) | 1 The Great One (2) | 6 The Dark Horse (1) | I Got Stones (2) | nWo Wolfpac (1) | Tha Preda~Toe (1) | Dirty Laundry (1) |
| 2021 | 6 💥Mega Powers💥 (1) | 4 The Fresh Crew (2) | 1 The Great One (1) | The Dark Horse (1) | No Haters Allowed (2) | No Haters Allowed (1) | The Great One (1) |
| 2022 | 4 🏈 TOE DRAGG SWAGG 🏈 (1) | 2 Flint Tropics (1) | 6 Dirty Laundry (1) | Swag Sold Separately (1) | No Haters Allowed (3) | 🏈 TOE DRAGG SWAGG 🏈 (2) | Mr. steal yo Gurley (1) |
| 2023 | 1 Flint Tropics (1) | 2 LeDark Horse (5) | 4 Dirty Laundry (2) | No Haters Allowed (3) | 🏈 TOE DRAGG SWAGG 🏈 (1) | No Haters Allowed (2) | LeDark Horse (2) |
| 2024 | 2 LeDark Horse (1) | 1 🌵Death by Saguaro🌵 (1) | 3 No Haters Allowed (1) | 🏈 TOE DRAGG SWAGG 🏈 (1) | Toomuchtoolate (1) | Dirty Laundry (1) | 🌵Death by Saguaro🌵 (3) |
| 2025 | 2 🌵Death by Saguaro🌵 (2) | 5 No Haters Allowed (2) | 3 Django Achaned (2) | 💥Mega Powers💥(2) | Salsa Dancers (2) | 🏈 TOE DRAGG SWAGG 🏈 (3) | 🌵Death by Saguaro🌵 (4) |
extraordinarilyfreshffl.com 